What is authentic acting? Why is planning how to play a scene bad?
Authentic acting means that the actor is moving in accord to the complex emotions of the character. The actor should never have a plan on how to play a scene because the moment is only understood in the scene. The "performance" is in reality, simply a plan that becomes mechanical very fast. Thinking what the character is feeling will result in a more authentic acting. The director, in this case, needs to stop ordering specifics from the actor. The actor must think for themselves in how the character will think in the moment. Demanding an end result is confusing and infuriating to some actors.